George Frideric Handel:
  
Messiah

Boston Baroque Performances

Oratorio in three parts
Libretto adapted from biblical verses by Charles Jennens
First performance: Dublin, April 13, 1742

Program Notes by Martin Pearlman

One of the special challenges in performing Messiah year after year is to keep the work sounding fresh, as if one had just discovered it. When Boston Baroque gave the first Boston period-instrument performances of the complete oratorio in 1981, the work was still normally heard in this country in the relatively heavy, reverential style of the nineteenth century. It was thus a surprise to many listeners to hear a more detailed, articulate style and quicker tempos based on Baroque dance rhythms and speech patterns. This kind of performance was perhaps less in the spirit of church music -- Handel never performed Messiah in a church -- and more in the spirit of the theater, or of a "fine Entertainment," as Handel's librettist Charles Jennens called it.

Today, such an interpretation is much more common among both period and modern orchestras, and it is no longer surprising. Instead, a listener can focus on the drama of the work and how a particular performance presents it. I personally have found it satisfying to return to the work each year not so much to perform different versions of it or to consciously try to do something "different," but rather to discover more details and greater depth in the music. For me, that is what makes it perpetually "new." A work such as Messiah is inexhaustible.

The Italian love duets

Among the many avenues to explore in this work, are the original versions of some of the choruses. Shortly before he composed Messiah, Handel wrote a small collection of Italian love duets for two voices and continuo, of which he used five as the basis for movements in his oratorio. In Part I, these include the choruses "And He shall purify," "For unto us a child is born," and "His yoke is easy," and in Part II, "All we like sheep." In Part III, the short duet, "O death, where is thy sting" is also based on one of his love duets, but it remains a duet with continuo in the oratorio. It is fascinating to compare musical ideas in Messiah with those in the original Italian duets. The musical emphasis on the first word of "For unto us" has struck some people as odd, but it originally came on the strong word "No!" in the Italian duet. Similarly, the little rhythmic hiccup on the word "easy" in "His yoke is easy" may not sound particularly "easy," but it illustrated the word "ride" (laugh) in the original duet. It can also be revelatory to realize that portions of these choruses are still duets -- i. e. that there are often only two voice parts at a time, with the full chorus sounding mainly at climactic moments.

"Speaking" and "singing" music

The chorus has the greatest role of any actor in Messiah. Its music constantly shifts between a kind of "speaking" music, which declaims speech patterns in the text, and a more lyrical "singing" music. Much as dance rhythms can influence the tempo and character of a piece, the speech patterns of the text can often suggest a natural tempo. But "speaking" music is not only rhythmic; it also has very flexible, detailed dynamics, as in actual speech, where the sound of even a single syllable may sometimes die away. A more powerful type of spoken declamation often comes at climactic moments, such as at the words "Wonderful, counselor" in the chorus "For unto us a child is born." The playing of the orchestra too can reflect the rhythmic quality and detailed dynamics of the speech patterns in the text, an effect that is perhaps more natural for Baroque instruments but that can be achieved on modern instruments, as well.

The libretto and the drama

In creating his libretto, Charles Jennens interspersed texts from both the Old Testament prophets and the New Testament to depict in a general way the story of the messiah. Although the oratorio is primarily contemplative, with no speaking characters and hardly any action, it does fall into several dramatic scenes, which demand a degree of continuity between movements in performance. The first scene, running from the overture through the chorus "For unto us a child is born," prefigures the arrival of the messiah. The second opens with an instrumental interlude depicting the shepherds' pipes (Pifa) and the angel announcing the birth of Jesus; it is the only truly narrative moment in the oratorio and ends with angels gradually disappearing as the music fades away. Part I concludes with rejoicing.

Part II falls into two large scenes, the first reflecting on the suffering, death and resurrection of Jesus, and the second depicting the spread of the Gospel. Part III is a section of contemplation and thanksgiving, based on the Anglican burial service.

In places, these scenes are unified by recurring figuration in the music: the sharp, dotted rhythms representing the scourging of Jesus in Part II first appear in the middle section of the aria "He was despised", then again in the following chorus ("Surely, he hath borne our griefs"), and yet again in the recitative ("All they that see him laugh him to scorn"). Sometimes scenes are unified by pieces in related tempos or in similar affects. An example of the latter occurs at the end of Part II, where a string of violent images ("Why do the nations so furiously rage together", "Thou shalt break them with a rod of iron") is crowned with the chorus "Hallelujah." In this context, "Hallelujah" becomes not only a shout of joy but also something of a war cry.

Historical background

When Charles Jennens presented Handel with his text for Messiah in 1741, Handel's fortunes were so low that he was considering leaving England. Several years earlier, his opera company had collapsed and he had suffered a stroke. In the years following his recovery, he had had great success with two English oratorios (Saul and L'Allegro), but his two Italian operas had been complete failures. With the fashion for Italian opera apparently over, Jennens hoped to persuade Handel to write more English oratorios.

In the summer of 1741 came a fortuitous invitation to give a series of concerts in Dublin. With these concerts in mind, Handel set to work on the music for Messiah on August 22, completing the enormous work on September 14, a mere three weeks later. Jennens, never one to be overly modest, expressed disappointment that Handel had not spent a year setting his libretto. "[Handel] has made a fine Entertainment of it, tho' not near so good as he might & ought to have done. I have with great difficulty made him correct some of the grossest faults in the composition, but he retain'd his Overture obstinately, in which there are some passages far unworthy of Handel, but much more unworthy of the Messiah."

Messiah was premiered on April 13, 1742 in Dublin for the benefit of charity and drew so many people that ladies were requested not to wear hoops, in order to accommodate a larger audience. The series of concerts was a triumph. According to Faulkner's Journal, "The best judges allowed it to be the most finished piece of Musick. Words are wanting to express the exquisite Delight it afforded to the admiring crowded Audience."

But Handel was wary about presenting his new oratorio in London. Several years earlier, Israel in Egypt had failed, partly due to a controversy over using a biblical text in the theater. When he did finally introduce Messiah there in 1743, it was not well received, partly indeed because of its biblical text, but also partly because there were so many choruses and no characters playing out a story. The work did not become widely accepted until he began presenting it in his annual charity performances for the Foundling Hospital in 1750. Between that time and Handel's death in 1759, Messiah attained the exalted stature it has held to the present day, a musical tradition unparalleled in the English-speaking world.

Performing versions

In Messiah, as in many of his other works, Handel made numerous changes for later performances. Many of these alterations, such as moving an aria from one voice range to another, were made simply to accommodate a new singer and do not necessarily reflect his final preference for how a movement ought to go. Other changes, however, appear to be attempts to improve the work and must be taken into account in a modern performance. There is no definitive version. A modern performer must look at the various versions presented in the different manuscripts (sometimes there is more than one version in the same manuscript), try to understand the reasons for the changes, and make decisions about the best version to use.

Handel's autograph score survives, and, while it contains the original version of the work, he seems to have changed his mind about certain pieces even before the first performance. At least as important as the autograph is a score which Handel apparently used in Dublin and in certain later performances. It is in the hand of Handel's copyist, but Handel himself has made many changes and marginal notes, including writing in names of singers. A third important version is a manuscript, again by a copyist, bequeathed by Handel in his will to the Foundling Hospital, for which he had given benefit concerts. This Foundling Hospital score appears never to have been used, but with it there is a valuable set of orchestral and vocal parts which formed the basis for many of his later performances. There are other sources, but these three -- the autograph, Dublin and Foundling Hospital -- have the greatest authority from Handel's own performances.

Boston Baroque Performances

Messiah

December 3 & 4, 2022
Calderwood Studio at GBH, Boston, MA
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Heidi Stober, Soprano
Ann McMahon Quintero, mezzo-soprano
Thomas Cooley, tenor
Sidney Outlaw, baritone

December 10, 11 & 12, 2021
Calderwood Studio at GBH, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Maya Kherani, soprano
Christopher Lowrey, countertenor
Aaron Sheehan, tenor
Kevin Deas, bass-baritone

December 6 & 7, 2019
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Amanda Forsythe, soprano
Ann McMahon Quintero, mezzo-soprano
Thomas Cooley, tenor
Andrew Garland, baritone

December 7 & 8, 2018
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Layla Claire, soprano
Eric Jurenas, countertenor
Norman Shankle, tenor
Nathan Stark, bass-baritone

December 8 & 9, 2017
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Ava Pine, soprano
Paula Murrihy, mezzo-soprano
Aaron Sheehan, tenor
Stephen Powell, baritone

December 9 & 10, 2016
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Amanda Forsythe, soprano
Ann McMahon Quintero, mezzo-soprano
Joshua Kohl, tenor
Andrew Garland, baritone

April 1, 2015
NOSPR Hall, Katowice, Poland
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Yulia Van Doren, soprano
Ann McMahon Quintero, mezzo-soprano
Thomas Cooley, tenor
Kevin Deas, bass-baritone

December 12 & 13, 2014
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Sherezade Panthaki, soprano
William Burden, tenor
Dashon Burton, bass

December 13 & 14, 2013
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Kiera Duffy, soprano
Kate Lindsey, mezzo-soprano
Nicholas Phan, tenor
Jesse Blumberg, baritone

December 7 & 8, 2012
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Mary Wilson, soprano
Ann McMahon Quintero, mezzo-soprano
John McVeigh, tenor
Andrew Garland, baritone

December 9 & 10, 2011
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Ava Pine, soprano
Julia Mintzer, mezzo-soprano
Keith Jameson, tenor
Andrew Garland, baritone

December 10 & 11, 2010
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Amanda Forsythe, soprano
Matthew White, countertenor
Keith Jameson, tenor
Kevin Deas, bass-baritone

December 11 & 12, 2009
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Amanda Forsythe, soprano
Ann McMahon Quintero, mezzo-soprano
Lawrence Wiliford, tenor
Timothy Jones, bass-baritone

December 12 & 13, 2008
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Tamara Matthews, soprano
Alan Dornak, countertenor
Keith Jameson, tenor
Kevin Deas, bass-baritone

December 14 & 15, 2007
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Amanda Pabyan, soprano
Ann McMahon Quintero, mezzo-soprano
Kerem Kurk, tenor
Kevin Deas, bass-baritone

December 8 & 9, 2006
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Tamara Matthews, soprano
Ann McMahon Quintero, mezzo-soprano
Don Frazure, tenor
Michael Dean, bass-baritone

December 16 & 17, 2005
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Tamara Matthews, soprano
Kristin Watson, soprano
David Walker, countertenor
Keith Jameson, tenor
Michael Dean, bass-baritone

December 17 & 18, 2004
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Sari Gruber, soprano
Phyllis Pancella, mezzo-soprano
Keith Jameson, tenor
Stephen Powell, baritone

December 12 & 13, 2003
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Sharon Baker, soprano
David Walker, countertenor
Don Frazure, tenor
Michael Dean, bass-baritone

March 18, 2003
Warsaw Philharmonic Hall, Warsaw, Poland
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Sharon Baker, soprano
Mary Phillips, mezzo-soprano
Carl Halvorson, tenor
Kevin Deas, bass-baritone

March 17, 2003
Kraków Philharmonic Hall, Kraków, Poland
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Sharon Baker, soprano
Mary Phillips, mezzo-soprano
Carl Halvorson, tenor
Kevin Deas, bass-baritone

December 13 & 14, 2002
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Esther Heideman, soprano
Elizabeth Shammash, mezzo-soprano
Carl Halvorson, tenor
Kevin Deas, bass-baritone

December 14 & 15, 2001
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Esther Heideman, soprano
Deanne Meek, mezzo-soprano
Carl Halvorson, tenor
Dean Ely, bass

December 15 & 16, 2000
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Sharon Baker, soprano
Margaret Lattimore, mezzo-soprano
Mark Tucker, tenor
Dean Ely, bass

December 17 & 18, 1999
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Jennifer Welch, soprano
David Walker, countertenor
Gordon Gietz, tenor
Kevin Deas, bass-baritone

December 15, 1999
Portsmouth Music Hall, Portsmouth, NH
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Jennifer Welch, soprano
David Walker, countertenor
Gordon Gietz, tenor
Kevin Deas, bass-baritone

December 14, 1999
North Shore Music Theater, Beverly, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Jennifer Welch, soprano
David Walker, countertenor
Gordon Gietz, tenor
Kevin Deas, bass-baritone

December 18 & 19, 1998
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Sharon Baker, soprano
David Walker, countertenor
Gordon Gietz, tenor
Victor Ledbetter, baritone

December 16, 1998
Portsmouth Music Hall, Portsmouth, NH
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Sharon Baker, soprano
David Walker, countertenor
Gordon Gietz, tenor
Victor Ledbetter, baritone

December 19 & 20, 1997
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Sharon Baker, soprano
Beth Clayton, mezzo-soprano
Mark Bleeke, tenor
Kevin Deas, bass-baritone

December 17, 1997
Portsmouth Music Hall, Portsmouth, NH
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Sharon Baker, soprano
Beth Clayton, mezzo-soprano
Mark Bleeke, tenor
Kevin Deas, bass-baritone

December 22, 1996
Zeiterion Theater, New Bedford, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Brenda Harris, soprano
Laura Tucker, mezzo-soprano
Bruce Fowler, tenor
Victor Ledbetter, baritone

December 20 & 21, 1996
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Brenda Harris, soprano
Laura Tucker, mezzo-soprano
Bruce Fowler, tenor
Victor Ledbetter, baritone

December 16, 1995
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Brenda Harris, soprano
Jeffrey Gall, countertenor
Glenn Siebert, tenor
David Arnold, baritone

December 17, 1994
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Sharon Baker, soprano
Catherine Robbin, mezzo-soprano
Mark Bleeke, tenor
David Arnold, baritone

December 16, 1993
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Nancy Armstrong, soprano
Jeffrey Gall, countertenor
Steven Tharp, tenor
David Arnold, baritone

December 12, 1992
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Karen Clift, soprano
Jeffrey Gall, countertenor
Bruce Fowler, tenor
David Arnold, baritone

December 14, 1991
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Nancy Armstrong, soprano
Mary Ann Hart, mezzo-soprano
Frank Kelley, tenor
Erik Oland, baritone

December 14, 1990
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Carol Ann Allred, soprano
Dale Terbeck, countertenor
Christopher Hux, tenor
Myron Myers, bass

December 15, 1989
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Carol Ann Allred, soprano
Pamela Dellal, mezzo-soprano
Christopher Hux, tenor
William Parker, baritone

December 14, 1989
St. Anselm’s College, Manchester, NH
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Pamela Murray, soprano
Jean Danton, soprano
Pamela Dellal, mezzo-soprano
Christopher Hux, tenor
William Parker, baritone

December 9, 1988
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Nancy Armstrong, soprano
Thomas Mark Fallon, countertenor
Frank Kelley, tenor
Sanford Sylvan, baritone

December 9, 1988
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Nancy Armstrong, soprano
Thomas Mark Fallon, countertenor
Frank Kelley, tenor
Sanford Sylvan, baritone

December 11, 1987
NEC’s Jordan Hall, Boston, MA
Martin Pearlman, conductor

Soloists:
Sharon Baker, soprano
Steven Rickards, countertenor
Frank Kelley, tenor
David Evitts, baritone

December 14, 1986
Brightwaters, Long Island, NY
Martin Pearlman, conductor